Press Releases

Press Release

CONSERVATION GROUPS ASK STATE SUPREME COURT: INVALIDATE EVISCERATION OF OIL & GAS PIT RULE

CONTACTS:

Bruce Baizel, Executive Director, Earthworks’ Oil and Gas Accountability Project, (970) 799-3552

Judy Calman, Staff Attorney, New Mexico Wilderness Alliance, (505) 843-8696

Eric Jantz, Staff Attorney, New Mexico Environmental Law Center (505) 750-3027

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE:

Friday, March 25, 2016

WATER GROUPS ASK STATE SUPREME COURT:

INVALIDATE EVISCERATION OF OIL & GAS PIT RULE

“...the Oil Conservation Commission forgot who they worked for. It isn’t the oil and gas industry.”

Bruce Baizel, Executive Director, Earthworks’ OGAP

SANTA FE, NM — Yesterday, groups working to protect New Mexico’s water resources and wildlife asked the state Supreme Court to review the Martinez Administration’s “Pit Rule”. The Rule governs the storage and disposal of wastes at oil and gas drilling pits in New Mexico.

The petition for a writ of certiorari was filed by the New Mexico Environmental Law Center (NMELC) on behalf of Earthworks’ Oil and Gas Accountability Project and the New Mexico Wilderness Alliance. The public interest groups have been working on the issue since before the Pit Rule was first adopted in 2008, after a lengthy public process. The petition asks the state’s highest court to review a decision handed down by the state Court of Appeals in February upholding the amended Pit Rule.

In 2013, the Martinez-appointed Oil Conservation Commission, despite widespread public opposition, eliminated nearly every substantive provision on the Pit Rule at the behest of the oil and gas industry. See Pit Rule Fact Sheet.

In their petition, the groups ask for the Supreme Court to set aside the 2013 amendments that eviscerated the 2008 Pit Rule, based on the legal arguments that:

  • The Commission did not have authority to weaken the Pit Rule for purely economic reasons benefiting the oil and gas industry.
  • The Commission failed to explain the reasons for its abrupt change of policy in 2013, despite the Commissioners hearing nearly identical testimony as presented to the Commissioners who adopted the 2008 Pit Rule.
  • The Oil Conservation Commission violated the Separation of Powers Doctrine when it amended the Pit Rule while it was under appeal in state district court.

“Pits” store liquid and solid wastes created by drilling for oil and gas; they are located at or near the oil or gas wells. As written in 2008, the New Mexico Pit Rule was designed to protect soil and groundwater from toxic contaminants including arsenic, benzene, chromium and lead (see Pit Pollution: A Backgrounder on the Issues, with a New Mexico Case Study by the Earthworks for a list of contaminants commonly found in pits). As amended in 2013, the Pit Rule does little to protect our state’s water, public health or wildlife.

“The state of New Mexico is legally and by definition bound to serve all New Mexicans,” said Earthworks’ Oil and Gas Accountability Project Director Bruce Baizel. He continued, “In eviscerating the Pit Rule, the Oil Conservation Commission forgot who they worked for. It isn’t the oil and gas industry.”

"All New Mexicans, including the corporate entities that benefit from our state's natural resources, share a responsibility to be good citizens for our state's water and public lands," says Judy Calman, Staff Attorney at the New Mexico Wilderness Alliance. "That's why we're asking the Supreme Court to revert to the 2008 Pit Rule, which was protective of water, people and wildlife.” 

“There are serious legal flaws in the decision handed down by the state Court of Appeals when it upheld the Rule,” says Eric Jantz, Staff Attorney with the New Mexico Environmental Law Center. “The Supreme Court now has an excellent opportunity to send a strong message that politics don’t belong in rulemakings, and to affirm that our state’s regulatory decision-makers do not have the authority to change rules solely for the economic benefit of an industry to the detriment of other New Mexicans.”

The Supreme Court will notify the petitioners if it will review the case. See NMELC case page.

INTERVIEWS ARE AVAILABLE UPON REQUEST

For more than 25 years Earthworks’ Oil and Gas Accountability Project has been protecting communities and the environment from the negative impacts of resource extraction.

The New Mexico Environmental Law Center is a not-for-profit public-interest law firm working to protect the communities and environment of New Mexico. It was founded in 1987, and is based in Santa Fe, NM.

The New Mexico Wilderness Alliance is a 501(c)(3) non profit organization dedicated to the protection, restoration, and continued enjoyment of New Mexico's wild lands and wilderness areas.

###

Please reply to this email with UNSUBSCRIBE in the subject line if you wish to be removed from this list.

More Articles ...

  1. Week of celebrations will mark Organ Mountains-Desert Peaks’ 1st Anniversary
  2. 5th International Mexican Gray Wolf Stamp Released
  3. Land Transfer Bill Killed in Santa Fe
  4. Groundbreaking progress for New Mexico: U.S. House passes bill to create Columbine Hondo Wilderness
  5. U.S. Senate Committee Sends Columbine Hondo to Floor for Consideration
  6. New Mexico becomes wilderness headquarters
  7. NM Wild Staff Members Embark On Historic 50-Mile Gila Trek To Commemorate 90th Anniversary
  8. Organ Mountains-Desert Peaks National Monument to be Protected
  9. New Mexicans Send Clear Message to Sec. Jewell: Protect Organ Mountains-Desert Peaks
  10. RELEASE: Organ Mountains-Desert Peaks Legislation Introduced
  11. Columbine Hondo is key step closer to protection
  12. Proposed Massive Military Operations on the Cibola National Forest Questioned
  13. Mora County Becomes the First County in the United States to Permanently Ban the Extraction of Oil and Gas
  14. Announcement that Rio Grande del Norte To Become a National Monument is Cheered by the Local Community
  15. Website Launched to Celebrate Wilderness 50th Anniversary
  16. Northern New Mexicans urge federal delegation to protect Columbine Hondo: Lawmakers listen to community in coalition meeting
  17. Supporters back national monument status for Organ Mountains
  18. 2012 Limited Edition Mexican Wolf Conservation Stamp Released
  19. Nuestra Tierra, Our Land – Our Future Highlights Hispanic Support for Land Protection
  20. New Mexico Celebrates “Great Outdoors Week”
  21. Press Release: Hispano, Green Chambers of Commerce Applaud Reintroduction of Wilderness Protection Bill
  22. Press Release: Local Sportsmen and Back Country Horsemen Organizations Call for Protection of Wilderness
  23. Dona Ana County Wilderness Bill Reintroduced!
  24. Press Release: Mining Claims in Otero Mesa Nearly Triple
  25. Press Release: Sen. Bingaman Wins Praise for Reintroducing New Mexico Conservation Bill
  26. Otero Mesa Targeted by Mining Industry
  27. Press Release: New Forest Service Planning Rule Weakens Current Standards
  28. DoI Press Release: Spotlight on National Landscape Conservation System
  29. NMWA Awards First Conservation Wolf Stamp Grant
  30. New Report: Agency Coordination Improves Border Security and Public Lands Protection
  31. Governor Proclaims Roadless Recreation Week in New Mexico
  32. House Hearing for Cibola NF Expansion Bill
  33. Rep. Heinrich Introduces Bill Extending Cibola NF and Manzano Wilderness
  34. New Mexico Wilderness Alliance 2010 Wild Guide
  35. Northern New Mexico Wilderness Bill Heads to Senate Floor
  36. Doña Ana County Wilderness Bill Introduced!
  37. New Mexico Conservation Bill Takes Key Step Towards Passage
  38. Otero Mesa Victory!
  39. Congress Passes Bill That Protects Sabinoso
  40. New Study says Otero Mesa drilling would bring few economic benefits to New Mexico or Otero County
  41. 2009 Wild Guide Is Here!
  42. Sabinoso Wilderness – Victory!
  43. New Mexico Mining Claims Jump 50% Since 2003

Search

NM Wild Supporters

Press Releases Menu

  • Southern New Mexico Stands Up to President Trump’s Attack on Organ Mountains-Desert Peaks National Monument +

    Order could threaten national parks, monuments, and public lands across the country Las Cruces, New Mexico (April 26, 2017) – Read More
  • Taos News: The truth about the 'Protect the Pecos' campaign (2) +

    Printed in the Taos News, July 28, 2016 PDF of this Article There is an unfortunate impression by some that Read More
  • Conservationists Intervene on Behalf of Mexican Gray Wolf Reintroduction Efforts in New Mexico +

    Download the PDF   June 6, 2016Contacts:Defenders of Wildlife: Catalina Tresky (202) 772-0253, This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. for Biological Diversity: Michael Robinson (575) Read More
  • Santa Fe National Forest Public Meetings - April and May 2016 +

    SantaFe National Forest Plan Revision We Need YOUR Input! Learn about and provide input to the required Forest Plan Revision Read More
  • 6th International Mexican Wolf Stamp +

    2016 Limited Edition Mexican Wolf Conservation Stamp Released Sixth annual commemorative stamp supports conservation and education efforts for the endangered Read More
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 9
  • 10

Resources Menu

  • 1